Showing posts with label lawyers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label lawyers. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 28, 2011

Loughner's lawyers seek to halt forced medication (Reuters)

PHOENIX (Reuters) – Attorneys for Tucson shooting rampage suspect Jared Loughner have petitioned a federal court to order prison officials to stop forcibly medicating him with anti-psychotic drugs.

Loughner was declared mentally incompetent last month to stand trial on charges he killed six people and wounded 13 others, including Arizona Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords, and was sent back to a hospital for federal prisoners in Missouri.

U.S. District Judge Larry Burns has set a hearing for September 21 to determine whether Loughner's condition has improved enough for the proceedings against him to resume.

Court papers filed by his defense team last Friday argued that the U.S. Bureau of Prisons, "without the approval of the court, has decided to involuntarily and forcibly medicate Jared Loughner on the grounds that he is a danger to others."

Dr. Carlos Tomelleri, a psychiatrist evaluating Loughner, cited three recent outbursts by the 22-year-old college dropout as justification for administering medication to him against his will, the documents said.

Two of those incidents involved Loughner throwing a plastic chair inside his closed and locked cell, "the third involved spitting at counsel," the document stated.

But Loughner's defense team, led by attorney Judy Clarke, said there was "no evidence that any efforts were made to educate Mr. Loughner about the consequences of his behavior before seeking to forcibly medicate him with psychotropic drugs."

Loughner is accused of opening fire with a semiautomatic pistol on Giffords and a crowd of bystanders attending a political gathering outside a Tucson supermarket in January. Giffords, a third-term Democrat, is still recovering from a single gunshot wound to her head.

Loughner pleaded not guilty in March to 49 charges stemming from the shooting rampage at the "Congress on Your Corner" event, including multiple counts of first-degree murder.

He has been described by his lawyers as "gravely mentally ill." At the competency hearing in May, Burns cited the conclusions of two medical experts that Loughner suffers from schizophrenia, disordered thinking and delusions.

In a sign of his mental agitation during the hearing last month, Loughner rocked back and fourth, and was dragged from the courtroom shouting, "She died in front of me," shortly before Burns ruled him incompetent to stand trial.

(Editing by Steve Gorman)


View the original article here

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Anthony case recesses after judge criticizes lawyers (Reuters)

ORLANDO, Fla (Reuters) – Accusing the two lead lawyers in the Casey Anthony murder case of unrelenting gamesmanship, Chief Judge Belvin Perry threatened a stepped-up work schedule with "fierce days" as the trial began its fifth week.

Apparently exasperated Monday morning after extended discussions at the bench and in his chambers, the judge finally called a recess until Tuesday morning. No witness was called, and the jury had never entered the court.

"Enough is enough," the judge said. "Both sides need to be forewarned. I may have to consider exclusion of testimony, even at the price of having to do this all over. It may be the proper remedy if this continues."

Casey, 25, is accused by the prosecution of using duct tape to strangle her 2-year-old daughter, Caylee, on June 16, 2008, then storing her body in the trunk of a car.

As soon as court opened at 9 a.m. Monday, prosecutor Jeff Ashton and lead defense counsel Jose Baez were battling, accusing each other of delaying tactics while defending their own actions.

"If you two don't want to be professional, I'll start working you a real, full day, with short lunch hours. I have a sequestered jury to worry about," Perry told the lawyers.

"Look at the clock and tell me what time it is," he ordered. Ashton said: "9:25." Baez said: "9:26."

The judge shook his head, saying "That proves you two will never agree. Plan to work a full day on (next) Saturday."

Saturday sessions have been running half days.

Casey Anthony's defense attorneys maintain her daughter Caylee accidentally drowned in the Anthony family's backyard pool, and no one reported her death.

The child's skeletal remains were found in woods near the Anthony family's home in the Orlando area on December 11, 2008, following a nationwide search.

Monday marked the first day of the high-profile trial's fifth week. During the fourth week the prosecutors had concluded their presentation and the defense team began making its case.

Last Saturday, Judge Perry had warned attorneys the trial was not moving along quickly enough and threatened to extend each work day by an extra hour.

On Monday he made good on his threat by saying he was extending Saturday to a full day, and warning that he might have to exclude evidence if the games didn't stop.

Exclusion is an extreme sanction that can ultimately lead to an appeals court or the state Supreme Court throwing out the results of a trial and calling for a re-trial.

"I'm not surprised that Judge Perry has lost patience," said Robert Buonauro, a criminal trial lawyer who has practiced in Orlando for more than 20 years.

"The judge is a real no-nonsense guy, but he's also pretty cool. They must have pushed him to the limit."

Buonauro also said if the judge does exclude evidence, the defense might move for a mistrial.

Perry reminded both teams on Monday of the request he issued before the trial began, asking that each expert witness send a report that stated all opinions they were planning to give.

The reports would give both sides a clear view of the planned testimony of each witness, and avoid surprises during the trial. Perry said those rules had been violated by both sides, and he wanted it to stop.

The recess will give the prosecution time to review a defense witness deposition taken during the weekend, and allow both teams enough time to review their reports and depositions to see that all opinions are mentioned.

Spectators who had waited in line Saturday for Monday's seat passes grumbled while they headed to the elevator. Court administrators said there would be no rain checks.

(Editing by Jerry Norton)


View the original article here

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Phil Spector's lawyers seek rehearing of appeal (AP)

LOS ANGELES – Lawyers for music producer Phil Spector have asked an appeals court to take a second look at his arguments for a new trial, contending the court ignored a defense argument that the trial judge had violated his neutrality in the case.

In a petition to the California 2nd District Court of Appeal, attorneys said the court's rejection of Spector's murder conviction appeal has left the legal community incredulous.

They suggested the court failed to consider that Superior Court Judge Larry Paul Fidler violated his neutrality by allowing the prosecution to show photographs of him among prosecution witnesses. They said this was coupled with a videotape of the judge explaining key forensic evidence.

Dennis Riordan, joined by fellow attorneys Charles Sevilla and Donald M. Horgan, alleged that jurors watched the tape during prosecution closing arguments, a move that turned the judge into a witness.

"No aspect of the trial was more startling," Riordan said, noting that in discussions within the legal community, "the assertion that prosecutors included multiple images of the presiding judge among the photos of their witnesses is met without exception by shocked incredulity."

Spector, a legendary rock music producer, was convicted two years ago of fatally shooting actress Lana Clarkson at his Alhambra mansion in 2003. He is serving 19 years to life in prison on a second-degree murder conviction.

His first trial ended in a hung jury; the second ended in a conviction.

The videotape of Fidler was from a hearing in which the trial judge explained a forensic witness' testimony about blood back spatter on Clarkson's wrist. The appeal quoted a prosecutor's statement to jurors: "See with your own eyes where (the expert) and the judge indicated the back spatter was on Lana's wrist."

That and other statements made Fidler a witness for the prosecution, Riordan said, and the defense had no opportunity to cross-examine him.

Riordan said a judge is forbidden to testify for one side or the other in a trial over which he is presiding. When defense attorneys asked the judge to tell jurors his comments were not part of the evidence, Fidler refused, they said.

In rejecting the defense's original appeal, the California appellate court validated Fidler's actions. The May 2 opinion found that on the issue of the videotape, "a trial court's power, indeed its responsibility, to clarify testimony is well-settled in California."

The new defense petition called out a footnote in that opinion that said the judicial panel didn't address the photos of the Fidler because it was not raised as an independent issue in the opening brief. Spector's lawyers said in the new appeal that "the court cannot avoid confronting the significance of the photographic display by invoking a procedural bar."

Riordan said the defense would be taking other issues in the appeal to the California Supreme Court, but that the appellate court must first address the photo display, which was "the factual cornerstone of the defendant's federal constitutional claims."


View the original article here

Monday, June 13, 2011

Lawyers: Gay judge fit to rule on gay marriage (AP)

SAN FRANCISCO – Claims by the group that sponsored California's voter-approved same-sex marriage ban that the federal judge who overturned the law was biased because he is in a relationship with another man are "factually groundless and legally insupportable," lawyers for two same-sex couples said Friday.

The legal team that successfully challenged the ban in Chief U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker's court last year argued in legal papers that the now-retired jurist had no obligation to reveal his sexual orientation or relationship status before he ruled that Proposition 8 violated the civil rights of gay Californians.

The ban's backers "lack any factual basis to assume that Judge Walker wishes to marry...and instead rely on nothing more than the fact that he is gay, in a relationship with a person of the same sex, and recognizes in his decision the importance of marriage in American society," the attorneys wrote. "Such unvarnished speculation does not come close to meeting the statutory requirements for compelling a judge's recusal."

The religious coalition that sponsored Proposition 8 moved last month to have Walker's historic ruling invalidated on the grounds that he stood to personally benefit from it.

The group's lawyers asked Walker's successor as chief federal trial judge in San Francisco to rule that Walker should have disqualified himself from hearing the case or at least disclosed his same-sex relationship.

In disputing that assertion, lawyers Theodore Olson and David Boies, who represented George W. Bush and Al Gore in the contested 2000 presidential election, said a married heterosexual judge could have been accused of bias just as readily because Proposition 8's supporters argued at trial that legalizing same-sex marriages would undermine traditional unions and harm children.

"In fact, under proponents' reasoning, African-American and female judges would have been required to recuse themselves in the most important civil rights cases in American history and all judges would be required to disclose their most private thoughts and relationships in order to preside over any case that involves constitutional rights they might conceivably want to secure for themselves and their families," the couples' lawyers said. "That is not the law — and our nation is much the better for it."


View the original article here

Sunday, May 29, 2011

Day off before Blagojevich lawyers mount defense (AP)

CHICAGO – Rod Blagojevich's attorneys have a day off to make final preparations before they begin mounting a defense at the former Illinois governor's corruption retrial.

Judge James Zagel has business unrelated to the case Tuesday. So he delayed the restart of the trial until Wednesday.

Defense lawyers have said they'll call their first witnesses Wednesday. But they haven't provided any names.

They describe their witnesses as prominent people who've been subpoenaed previously.

That means the witnesses could include Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel. Emanuel hasn't been accused of wrongdoing. But his name came up often in government testimony.

Defense attorneys have left open the possibility of calling Blagojevich himself. But they may wait to decide that until others take the stand first.

Blagojevich faces 20 charges. He denies any wrongdoing.


View the original article here